Coke trade secrets case ‘something out of a spy novel’
ATLANTA – A secretary accused of helping two men steal trade secrets from The Coca-Cola Co. and trying to sell them to rival PepsiCo Inc. was ordered released on bond Thursday in a blockbuster case her lawyer likened to “a spy novel.”Joya Williams’ co-defendants, a pair of ex-cons who served time together at the same federal prison in Alabama, were detained pending a preliminary hearing for all three on Tuesday. Their attorneys would not say how Williams knew the two men.Williams’ lawyer, Wanda Jackson, said outside the federal courthouse that the defense needs to see the product sample her client allegedly stole from Coke to be able to defend her properly. Jackson also suggested the product may not be as secret as Coke has suggested.”It does sound like something out of a spy novel or movie,” Jackson told reporters outside the courthouse. “Why would they leave a product in an office that was easily accessible? What was in it.”Coke hasn’t said. Jackson said the defense should be able to test the product.”The whole thing belies common sense,” she said of the accusations.Don Samuel, a lawyer for co-defendant Edmund Duhaney, said it was his client who was duped.”I might more accurately characterize it as the two stooges – and my innocent client unwittingly along for the ride – meet Coke,” Samuel said. “I think that getting clearance to work on this case might rival the national security clearance I need to get for a terrorism case.”Williams, Duhaney and Ibrahim Dimson were arrested Wednesday – the day a $1.5 million transaction was to occur. They are charged with stealing confidential information, including a sample of a new drink, from Coke and trying to sell it to Pepsi.Williams, who worked as an administrative assistant for a Coke executive at the corporate headquarters in Atlanta, is accused of rifling through corporate files and stuffing documents and a new Coca-Cola product into a personal bag. She has since been fired, the judge said during Thursday’s hearing.The three suspects face charges of wire fraud and unlawfully stealing and selling Coke trade secrets.U.S. Magistrate Judge Joel Feldman also signed a protective order that prevents the defendants from revealing any secrets they know about the company to anyone other than their lawyers.A Coke lawyer, Stephen Cowen, told Feldman he also may seek to bar certain documents and other information from being turned over to the defense during discovery.Williams’ father, George Williams, told reporters he is standing by his daughter.”Up until this point, I believe she left each and every one of her other jobs in good standing,” George Williams said, adding that his daughter was excited to land a job at Coca Cola four or five years ago.As the suspects appeared in court, more details about their backgrounds emerged.At the time of the alleged theft, Williams, 41, of Norcross, Ga., had been working for a senior Coke manager, Javier Sanchez Lamelas, who is a global brand director for the beverage giant, the company said. She doesn’t have a criminal record, according to her attorney.Duhaney, of Decatur, Ga., who told the judge he is 42 though federal prosecutors list him as 43, served nearly 5 years of a 7-year sentence for possession of cocaine with intent to distribute at a federal prison in Montgomery, Ala., according to U.S. Bureau of Prisons spokesman Mike Truman. He was released in February 2005.Dimson, of New York, who told the judge he is 28 though prosecutors list him as 30, served less than 1 year of a 2-year sentence for conspiracy to commit bank fraud at the same prison as Duhaney, Truman said. He arrived in 2003 and was released in 2004, meaning he was there at the same time as Duhaney.Dimson and Williams are both seeking court-appointed counsel for the duration of their case, while Duhaney is being represented by noted Atlanta defense attorney Samuel.Coca-Cola and Pepsi, usually bitter enemies, worked together to foil the alleged trade secrets theft plot.According to prosecutors, on May 19, Purchase, N.Y.-based PepsiCo provided Coke with a copy of a letter mailed to Pepsi in an official Coca-Cola business envelope. The letter, postmarked from the Bronx in New York, was from an individual identifying himself as “Dirk,” who claimed to be employed at a high level with Coca-Cola and offered “very detailed and confidential information.” “Dirk” was later identified as Dimson, the FBI says.Coca-Cola immediately contacted the FBI and an undercover FBI investigation began.Prosecutors say Williams was the source of the information Dimson offered to provide to Pepsi. They say that “Dirk” provided an FBI undercover agent 14 pages of Coca-Cola documents marked classified and confidential. The company confirmed that the documents were valid and highly confidential and were considered trade secrets. Prosecutors say “Dirk” requested $10,000 for the documents.Later “Dirk” produced other documents that Coca-Cola confirmed were valid trade secrets of Coca-Cola. He also agreed to be paid $75,000 for the purchase of a highly confidential product sample from a new Coca Cola project, prosecutors said.During a meeting at the Atlanta airport, an undercover agent later paid “Dirk” part of that money, placing the cash inside a yellow Girl Scout cookie box. “Dirk” handed the agent some documents in an Armani bag and the Coke product sample, an FBI affidavit says.Then on June 27, an undercover FBI agent offered to buy other trade secret items for $1.5 million from “Dirk.” The same day a bank account was opened under the names of Duhaney and Dimson, and the address used on the account was that of Duhaney’s residence, prosecutors said.Video surveillance showed Williams at her desk at Coke headquarters going through multiple files looking for documents and stuffing them into bags. She also was observed holding a liquid container with a white label, which resembled the description of a new Coca-Cola product sample, before placing it into her personal bag, prosecutors say.