Edwards murder suspects want separate trials, prosecutors want them tried together
February 16, 2018
EAGLE — The District Attorney's Office wants one trial for both people charged with murdering a beloved Edwards woman.
Their defense attorneys want them to stand trial separately.
In a short hearing Friday afternoon, Feb. 16, District Court Judge Paul Dunkelman said he would decide that and dozens of other issues as the case moves forward.
Leigha Paige Ackerson and Jacob Taylor White appeared before Dunkelman to be advised that they each face eight felony charges for allegedly murdering Catherine Kelley.
They appeared in court separately Friday, Ackerson first and then White, both shackled with a thick leather belt at the waist, with handcuffs and ankle shackles on two-foot chains binding them with chains strung through their belts.
Dunkelman advised them that they are charged with eight felonies, topped by first-degree murder. If they're convicted, then they'll go to prison for the rest of their lives.
Recommended Stories For You
The judge then asked them if they had questions. Neither did.
They're back in court at 9 a.m. Monday, April 16, for a two-day preliminary hearing. Attorneys with the case said it could take a year and a half for the murder case to come to trial.
Public Defender withdraws
The Public Defenders Office asked to withdraw as White's attorney because of a potential conflict between a witness and a member of the Public Defenders' staff. What that conflict might be was not disclosed during Friday's hearing.
Dunkelman said the court would appoint White a different attorney, which is his Constitutional right.
Eagle County Coroner Kara Bettis determined that Kelley was strangled to death. Eagle County Sheriff's deputies found her body in her Pilgrim Downs home Wednesday, Jan. 24.
Ackerson and White are charged with breaking into Kelley's home, robbing it and killing her.
Law enforcement cordoned off the area and, after a systematic search, found the two and the dog they brought with them.
An Uber driver waiting at the locked Pilgrim Downs gate told the property manager he was waiting to pick up two passengers, according to the arrest affidavit.
Staff Writer Randy Wyrick can be reached at 970-748-2935 or firstname.lastname@example.org.
Trending In: Crime
- Alleged Avon stabber moved to valley in April; Andrew Young Jr.’s bond set at $2 million in attempted murder case
- Life sentence for John Vasquez, who burned Christina Aruchuleta-Blasier to death in front of her children during camping trip
- Avon woman stabbed five times, suspect spotted with blood on his hands, pool of blood outside his door, police say
- Minturn man pleads guilty on attempted murder charge
- Alleged murderer pleads not guilty; October trial set for Jacob White, Catherine Kelley’s alleged killer
- Vail Valley churches, law enforcement plan for protests by Westboro Baptist Church
- Fire forcing evacuations in part of Oak Meadows outside Glenwood Springs
- Five local farmers markets coming to Vail Valley this summer
- Crowds enthusiastically embrace first two shows of Whistle Pig Vail concert series: Dispatch, Robert Plant
- Eagle Flight Days was fun for all in downvalley town (photo gallery)