Teen boys acquitted in assault trial
February 1, 2017
EAGLE — A jury spent less than three hours to reach a not-guilty verdict in a juvenile sexual assault trial.
The two-week trial, the first juvenile trial in local memory, ended with the acquittal of two teenage boy's New Year's Eve party in 2015 which ended with a sexual encounter with a teenage girl.
Prosecutors built their case around the assertion that the teenage girl was too drunk to knowingly consent to sex. Prosecutor Kelsy Sargent told the jury the girl was "incapable of appraising the nature of her own conduct."
Four hours after the party ended, the girl's blood alcohol content was .238, according to testimony.
“If it makes a reasonable person hesitate, that’s reasonable doubt. The only way you could get to guilty is if this boy knew that that girl was incapable of understanding the nature of her conduct.”Katheryn StimsonDefense attorney
Recommended Stories For You
Defense attorneys Katheryn Stimson and Marci Gilligan-LaBranche argued that the girl's drinking did not hit her completely until after the sexual encounter, and that she was in control of her own actions and decisions.
"In the United States of America, we are presumed innocent," Stimson said during closing arguments. "You'd better believe this is important to these two teenage boys and their mom. This is the most important day of their lives."
Stimson and Gilligan-LaBranche repeatedly stressed the high standard of "reasonable doubt" in criminal cases. They told jurors if they harbored reasonable doubt, then they must vote to acquit the boys.
Three hours later, the six-person jury had voted to do exactly that.
"If it makes a reasonable person hesitate, that's reasonable doubt, Stimson said. "The only way you could get to guilty is if this boy knew that that girl was incapable of understanding the nature of her conduct."
Staff Writer Randy Wyrick can be reached at 970-748-2935 and email@example.com.
Trending In: Crime
- Catherine Kelley’s murderer pleads guilty to killing Vail Valley woman, says he ‘hates’ what he did
- Valerie Demarco sentenced to 10 years in Vail Valley forgery scheme
- Accused Vail Valley murderer Leigha Ackerson to get psychiatric exam in state prison mental hospital
- Ritz Bachelor Gulch owner opts to fight felony charges
- Judge calls Pedro Gonzalez attempted murder case ‘unexplainable’ in handing down 42-year sentence
- Arson on the mountain: Vail’s 1998 arson fires at Two Elk were country’s worst eco-terrorist attack
- Former Vail Valley arts patron Alberto Vilar trying to enjoy what’s left of his life after 10-year prison stint
- Town of Vail likely to change short-term rental regulations in response to complaints
- Aspen girl speaks out in video about alleged rape
- Fire is burning north of Dotsero, near Sweetwater resort