The Longevity Project | Part 1: Why do residents of Colorado’s mountain towns live longer than anyone else in the country?
Deepan Dutta | For the Vail Daily
Chuck Kauffman talks about his lifestyle at 81, and what he thinks is the key to living long.If you ask some folks in Eagle and its neighboring counties, the answer is as clear as the air: It’s just about enjoying life. There’s an energizing force that seems to float off the mountains in puffs of powder. Every day offers a new wonder to explore and a new adventure to take with like-minded friends. Perhaps the fountain of youth melts out of the peaks and flows down into the valleys. However, the answer likely isn’t so mystical: Medical experts say these marvels of longevity tend to be affluent, educated, physically active, socially engaged and possibly genetically gifted. They don’t smoke, they watch what they eat, and they have access to high-quality health care. It’s the mountainous splendor of Colorado that then draws them all together. In this first installment in a four-part series on longevity, the Vail Daily, in partnership with the Summit Daily News, will dig deeper into why people in the state’s central mountains live longer than anyone else in the United States. And as the series progresses over the next three Tuesdays, we’ll also look at how the Ageless Alps of Colorado stack up against so-called “Blue Zones,” geographically isolated areas throughout the world where people live well into their 100s. Additionally, we’ll weigh the pluses and minuses of mountain culture, where residents play (and drink) hard, but also battle significant mental health challenges and economic inequality. And then we’ll peer into the future to see just how well-prepared we are to care for our aging population. A HIGH HONOR A report published last year by the University of Washington’s Institute for Health Metrics and Evaluation (IHME) set mountain towns abuzz. Titled “Inequalities in Life Expectancy Among US Counties, 1980 to 2014,” the study found that Summit and neighboring Pitkin and Eagle counties had the highest life expectancies in the nation at 86.83, 86.52 and 85.94 years, respectively. Meanwhile, a 2014 report published in the Aging and Disease medical journal found an association between living at high altitude and “lower mortality from cardiovascular diseases, stroke and certain types of cancer.” When it comes to health grades, central Colorado’s mountain counties are at the top of the class. So what’s their secret? To uncover the key to a long life, the IHME looked to death records. Its study then gleaned what impact socioeconomic factors, health care and behavior each had on life expectancy, based on Census data at a county level. Dr. Ali Mokdad, a co-author of the report and a professor of global health at the University of Washington, explained how each factor weighs in. Socioeconomic dynamics: Being wealthy and educated helps — a lot, he said. A person born in Summit County, with a median income of $70,192 and half the population touting college degrees (as of 2016), is expected to live 20 years longer than a person born in Oglala Lakota County, South Dakota, which has a life expectancy of 66.81 years, a median income of $26,330 and around 11 percent of the population attaining a college degree. But the impact of socioeconomic factors is deeper than the numbers. The right combination of education and wealth allows a person to both be aware of what they need to live longer, as well as being able to afford the means to do so. “For example,” Mokdad said, “a highly educated mother is more likely to understand danger signs for her health or her child. She’s more likely to afford and obtain medical care, more likely to understand medical advice and implement it.” Socioeconomic factors also affect awareness and affordability of a balanced diet, physical fitness and avoidance of risk factors, such as smoking and excess drinking. Being well-off also affords individuals more opportunities for recreational and social activities, which can impact physical and mental health and, by extension, life expectancy. Frank Walter Tuesday, Jan. 16, in Copper.Health care: Similarly, access and proximity to solid health insurance and quality health care is based, in large part, on geography and income. Summit and Eagle counties have a level III trauma center, St. Anthony Summit Medical Center in Summit and Vail Health in Vail. Eagle County has an assisted living center for seniors in Castle Peak Senior Care Community. When it comes to life-or-death emergencies, every second matters. Mokdad, who is based in Seattle, gives an example of what that means in practice. “Say I have a heart attack, here in Seattle,” he said. “It would take 10 minutes for me to get admitted to one of the best medical centers in the country.” On the other hand, a person in rural Eastern Washington, or in the western plains of Colorado, might be hours away from the nearest trauma center. According to the Colorado Rural Health Center, 85 percent of Americans can reach a level I or level II trauma center within an hour, but only 24 percent of rural Americans can do so within that timeframe, helping explain why 60 percent of all trauma deaths occur in rural areas. The type and quality of medical specialists available locally or regionally also contributes to the health care factor. While many mountain communities like Eagle and Summit counties lack full-time specialists in some areas, access to treatments for chronic illnesses has been improving. St. Anthony opened a specialty care and infusion center last year that offers chemotherapy and IV treatment for other chronic diseases like Crohn’s disease. “We’re a county that has a hospital and medical care, unlike other rural areas that don’t have access to good medical care,” said Dr. Peter Lemis, a cardiologist practicing in Frisco at Summit Cardiology. “The emergency response teams, and the fact that we have a hospital here … definitely contribute to the health of the county and have helped save many lives.” Behavioral and metabolic risks: The IHME study found that preventative behavioral risk factors such as smoking, drinking, drug use and obesity have the most to do with longevity, accounting for 74 percent of the variation in life expectancy between counties. According to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, the life expectancy for smokers is 10 years less than nonsmokers. A National Institutes of Health study has found that extreme obesity can reduce life expectancy by as much as 14 years. Both are major risk factors for cancer. Mokdad said managing preventable risk factors is crucial because it can counteract the socioeconomic factors that would normally hobble life expectancy. “There is a county in Arizona that has improved tremendously, despite the odds,” he said, referring to Yuma County, Arizona, which has a relatively low income level of around $41,000 yet has seen an eight-year jump in life expectancy over the past 20 years. That kind of improvement in life expectancy is based largely on the proper management of preventable risk factors, either at a social or policy level, which can turn around the economic fortunes of a town. “You need to be healthy to get out of poverty,” he said. MOUNTAIN FIT Up in the mountains, being healthy seems to come naturally. Eagle County, for example, has an 11.8 percent obesity rate, the lowest in the country. The hundreds of opportunities for physical activity in the mountains are a primary reason for that low number. “Increased physical activity helps prevent heart disease and increases life expectancy,” Lemis said. A National Institutes of Health study confirms that, finding that moderate to vigorous leisure-time physical activity can increase life expectancy by up to 4.5 years. “There are so many opportunities for seniors here to remain active, physically and mentally,” said Gini Patterson, a physical therapist and executive director of Timberline Adult Day Services, which provides daytime care for adults with daily living challenges. She gave several examples of places seniors can find these opportunities, such as Timberline, the Summit Senior Community Center and the “Over the Hill Gang” at Copper Mountain, a club for skiing seniors. PRIME EXAMPLE Kauffman fits the mold of a very active mountain senior. He is the oldest member of the Summit Mountain Biking Club, which includes members in their 50s to 80s. In 2016, he celebrated his 80th birthday by getting 35 friends to join him on a two-week biking trip through the Austrian Alps. He goes on bike trips with friends and family, skis 30 to 40 times a year and attends social gatherings with his many friends in the area. “I’ve found that there’s actually too many things to do around here,” Kauffman said. “The only time I really sit around is on Sunday during football games. But I’ll record that if I have to. I won’t let it get in the way of my biking.” He also avoids the habits that shorten lifespan. He eats moderately, even if he enjoys sweets now and then. “I’ve never been drunk, never had a hangover,” he said. “I smoked once, wound up burning a whole field down. Never did that again.” Retired Summit County general surgeon Dr. Don Parsons has treated patients in Summit for decades. He said mountain residents like Kauffman live longer because they follow the five rules he prescribes for a longer life. “Don’t smoke, control your weight, eat a plant-based, whole-food diet, exercise and have good social connections,” he said. “Summit County is absolutely ideal for all of those. We’re a community that really functions as a community. There are a lot of interconnections, a lot of volunteer opportunities. There are rock climbing clubs, ski clubs, bike clubs — all kinds of activities that bring people together.” NATURAL SELECTION? But how much of the high life expectancy here has to do with the fact that Summit and Eagle county residents are a self-selected group well-adapted to mountain life? Dr. Jules Rosen is the chief medical officer at Mind Springs Health and the former chief of geriatric psychiatry at the University of Pittsburgh. He believes the mountains filter out anyone who can’t acclimate or afford the lifestyle, but living up here doesn’t make people healthier. “It’s a self-selection of people who choose to live here,” he said. “If you don’t engage in that outdoors, active lifestyle, you probably won’t experience any benefits of living at altitude. There is no benefit just for living at 10,000 feet.” Lemis agrees with that assessment. “Most people who live here weren’t born here,” he said. “We went from a few thousand people in Summit in the 1960s to almost 30,000 people in the county now as residents.” He points out that the type of people who move into the county are active and healthy to begin with. “People with pre-existing conditions don’t move here, for the most part,” he said. Conditions that are exacerbated by elevation-related illnesses include high-altitude pulmonary edema, a condition that causes fluid buildup in the lungs, as well as central sleep apnea, which is caused by the pressure and oxygen changes associated with altitude. Rosen and Lemis both believe the high life expectancy number to be somewhat artificial. They point to the fact that once seniors are unable to have their needs met in the mountains, they must move elsewhere. Reasons can include wanting to be close to family who have already moved, needing special medical treatment or moving into a senior living facility that can better care for them. They tend not to come back, and they die elsewhere. That skews the numbers, they argued. “When people develop a medical condition that makes it harder to live at high altitude where there is 20 percent less oxygen at sea level, they might move,” Lemis said. “Another issue is if they get severely ill and need to be hospitalized beyond the level of care Summit can provide, they might move or get transferred to Denver and die there. So we don’t have as many people die here for that reason.” The Summit County Coroner’s Office reported in 2016 that the county had 10 “out-of-jurisdiction” cases, which involve patients who started dying in Summit but were transferred out of the county and passed away elsewhere. The coroner reported 82 deaths in Summit in 2016, and 42 of those deaths were visitors from outside the county. Mokdad said that the IMHE report did take migration into account, but it was not a big factor for life expectancy. Frank Walters skiing at Copper Mountain Wednesday, Jan. 17. THE X FACTOR There seems to be another factor at play that’s apparent whenever you speak to one of our mountain seniors, an inner drive that pushes them to get up early every day and take in all the high country has to offer. It’s a rugged stubbornness, a determination to not let time get ahead of them and to never say “die.” As Chuck Kauffman says, it’s a drive that keeps them from ever sitting still. That factor may remain unquantifiable, but it could very well be one of the keys to a longer, happier, healthier life. Read The Longevity Project | Part 2: How do Colorado’s long-lived mountain towns stack up to the rest of the world?