Researchers, artist turn up noise to battle pine beetles
Associated Press Writer
DENVER – Researchers from Arizona and a composer from New Mexico have teamed up to launch an acoustic counterattack against beetles that have ravaged millions of acres of trees across the West.
The tiny insects make squeaking noises as they tunnel through trees, and now a team at Northern Arizona University is using the beetles’ own communication against them.
The researchers have been manipulating the beetle sounds, which are above human hearing, and playing them back to the insects. The results drive them buggy: They attack each other, scamper in circles rather than straight lines and have tried to gnaw their way through Plexiglas covering a cross section of a tree in a lab in Flagstaff, Ariz.
“We found pretty amazing results when we would play back the sounds to bark beetles. We could disrupt their behavior,” said Richard Hofstetter, an assistant professor at Northern Arizona University’s forestry school.
The goal is to stop the beetle’s relentless march through Western forests. Hofstetter and anthropology student Reagan McGuire were studying ways to disrupt the beetles by bombarding them with sound when they heard of artist, musician and composer David Dunn, who tapped into pinon pine trees in New Mexico to record the bugs at work.
Dunn, president of the Art and Science Laboratory in Santa Fe, turned the insects’ birdlike chirps, squeaks and scratching against the backdrop of the trees’ noises into a compact disc, “The Sound of Light in Trees.”
“The massive die-off of trees just sort of made me curious – if these things are that energetic, maybe they’re making interesting sounds,” Dunn said.
At Northern Arizona University, McGuire had gone to Hofstetter with his idea of using law-enforcement-style “crowd-control sonic bullets,” but didn’t get anywhere blasting the beetles with heavy metal rock music and Rush Limbaugh broadcasts. The sounds irritated McGuire, but didn’t appear to bother the beetles.
Then, Hofstetter and McGuire, drawing on Dunn’s work, started using the beetles’ own communication against them. After identifying certain sounds with certain behaviors, the researchers manipulated beetle noises to interrupt the bugs’ mating or provoke them to attack each other.
“There’d be a male and female, they would mate, do all the normal things,” McGuire said, “and two hours later, he’d chew her to pieces. That’s not natural.”
Scientists have used beetles’ own chemicals to try to control them. Forest managers are watching to see if acoustics offer another route, said Skye Stephens, an entomologist with the Colorado State Forest Service.
The U.S. Forest Service recently approved $40 million to fight the beetle in the Rockies, where 3.6 million acres of pines have been decimated over the last decade in north-central Colorado and southeastern Wyoming.
Millions of more acres in Arizona, New Mexico, Montana, Idaho, Washington, Oregon and western Canada have been infested by the beetle, which is the size of a rice kernel.
Such outbreaks are part of natural cycles in forests, but state and federal land managers say this epidemic – the largest on record – has been aggravated by a lack of long frigid bouts to kill the bugs and drought that has weakened the trees.
“It kind of breaks all the rules,” Stephens said of the infestation.
The bugs burrow under the bark and lay their eggs, turning green needles the color of rust as they bore through the tree’s vascular system and restrict its ability to draw water. Eventually the needles fall off and the tree turns gray.
Trees have been cut down to reduce the risk of wildfire and prevent toppling pines from injuring people, blocking roads and trails and damaging power lines.
Stephens, who knows Hofstetter from her studies at Northern Arizona University, said she isn’t sure how the sound-control process would be applied to such large landscapes and whether it would be economical.
“One of the questions is if we could effectively remove them from a particular tree or set of trees, where do they go, what happens to them?” Stephens said. “I’m very excited to see what happens next” with the research.
Hofstetter and McGuire are eager to run tests on the ground to answer questions like that. Working with Dunn, they have applied for a patent on a device that pumps in noise to throw off the beetles’ destructive course. Hofstetter said the sounds are at a frequency that shouldn’t bother other species.
The work has been a side project for the professor, who has struggled to scrape together funding for the research. McGuire is volunteering his time.
“We’re hoping it’s going to lead to a whole new field,” Hofstetter said.
Dunn, who has traveled the world collecting sounds of nature for his compositions, first started recording the inner life of trees in 2004. He took the kind of small microphone used in greeting cards to record and play, fastened it to a recycled meat thermometer and inserted it into the tree. While concerned about the dying trees and what they signal about climate change, Dunn has become intrigued by the beetles, “an absolutely fascinating form of life.”
“I fell in love with them,” Dunn said. “But then we’re watching them cannibalize each other. I always think, ‘How bad is this karma?’
“But if something really positive about forest health comes of it, perhaps it’s worth the price.”
Support Local Journalism
If you don't follow the rules, your comment may be deleted.
User Legend: Moderator Trusted User