Shaw Cancer Center breast specialists emphasize the value of mammograms |

Shaw Cancer Center breast specialists emphasize the value of mammograms

Shauna Farnell
Special to the Daily
Virginia Minnick, one of Sonnenalp Breast Center’s certified breast specialists, demonstrates how the breast center’s new 3D mammography technology works. Sonnenalp was an early adopter of 3D mammography with breast density software in Colorado.
Dann Coffey | Special to the Daily | 970-926-9424

What is 3D mammography?

3D mammography is the newest technology in breast imaging, providing a superior image to basic digital mammography. This level of clarity makes it hard for breast cancer to hide – saving lives and reducing call-back appointments.

Schedule a 3D mammogram by calling Sonnenalp Breast Center in Edwards at 970-569-7690.

The American Cancer Society estimates that 40,000 women will die from breast cancer this year. When it comes to life or death — and the quality of days in between — most of us prefer to be safe, rather than sorry, although there has been some debate in recent months as to the importance and efficacy of mammograms. A few articles even suggest that mammogram screening doesn’t help detect breast cancer or save lives. But the world’s top breast cancer specialists — including those right here in Vail —insist they are dead wrong.

Dangers of Misinformation

The misinformation is particularly dangerous because it has led to a decrease in breast screening. Many women now, particularly those between the ages of 40 and 50, are simply avoiding getting a mammogram because they have been led to believe it isn’t necessary.

“The first thing I’d say to them is don’t skip it,” said Dr. Janice Ugale, radiologist and breast imaging specialist at Shaw Regional Cancer Center’s Sonnenalp Breast Center. “One of the things we’ve found is that breast cancer tends to be more aggressive in younger women. When you look at 40- to 50-year-old women, they’re in the prime of their lives, they have jobs, children and it’s a big impact if they’re diagnosed too late. Stage 1 can be just a little blip on the radar of life. Please don’t skip your mammograms.”

Support Local Journalism

The Canadian study that triggered the recent controversy – released in the British Medical Journal, but proven to be highly flawed and nearly 20 years old – implied that early detection of breast cancer is unnecessary and that women don’t need to be screened until they’re 60 years old.

Return to ‘Dark Ages’

Dr. Laszlo Tabar, renowned international expert in radiology and mammography, chastised an article published in the New York Times this winter that cited the study for launching “new doubts about the value of mammograms.”

Tabar, who like Ugale, has studied breast cancer for more than 40 years, accuses the study and its publicity as returning to “the dark ages in breast screening.”

Dr. Paula Gordon, clinical professor at the University of British Columbia, wrote a lashing retort to the New York Times article, saying, “It’s just wrong that a poorly designed and poorly executed study done decades ago in Canada could potentially cost thousands of American and Canadian women’s lives. It will dissuade women from having mammograms, and women will die.”

3D Mammography

The Sonnenalp Breast Center at Shaw Regional Cancer Center is now home to 3D mammography, which is considered the most accurate, state-of-the-art screening available. Sonnenalp has been accredited by The American College of Radiology as a “Breast Imaging Center of Excellence.”

Ugale points out that “it’s a really big deal for us to attain this designation,” and that the honor was awarded for the Sonnenalp Breast Center’s advanced technology in mammography, biopsies, ultrasounds and the entire staff’s specialization in breast imaging.

At the Sonnenalp Breast Center, mammography technologist Colleen Berga points out that women who have mammograms detecting Stage 1 breast cancer have almost a 97 percent survival rate when treated at Shaw, compared to a national average of 92.2. Contrary to the Canadian study and any other that attempts to devalue it, mammography is still, as Ugale puts it, “the gold standard in breast cancer screening.”

“We know that detecting early breast cancer gives a woman the best chance at survival,” she said, emphasizing that every woman aged 40 and older should get a mammogram once a year.

In August, 3D mammography will also be available in Summit County when the Shaw Breast Center and Cancer Clinic opens in Frisco at 323 West Main Street. The Frisco clinic will be the only breast center in Summit County with 3D mammography and staffed by certified breast experts.

Schedule a 3D mammogram by calling Sonnenalp Breast Center in Edwards at 970-569-7690.

Shauna Farnell is a freelance writer contracted by Vail Valley Medical Center to write this story. Email comments to

Support Local Journalism