Vail Daily health story: Is it the flu or a cold?

Dr. Dennis Lipton and S. Jason Moore
Special to the Weekly
S. Jason Moore

Breakout Box:

Decoding cold-related medicines:

• Tylenol, ibuprofen or naproxen for pain.

• Pseudoephedrine is good for congestion if you don’t have high blood pressure.

• Afrin nasal spray can also help on a very short-term basis.

• Salt water gargles, throat lozenges and saline nasal spray can also help relieve symptoms.

• Antihistamines may help with sneezing, runny nose and watery eyes but can cause sedation.

• Over-the-counter cough preparations have not been proven to do much.

• Zinc lozenges were once thought to reduce cold duration and symptoms, but repeat studies have failed to show benefit, and in fact have shown potential harm.

• Your doctor is not much help with a cold. The most we can do is prescribe a nasal spray that can help dry out your nose if your runny nose is truly intolerable.

• Antibiotics do not help with a cold, and, in fact, can make your recovery take longer.

EAGLE COUNTY — Colorado, along with much of the United States, is experiencing a high level of influenza-related illness. Vail Valley Medical Center has seen about 5 percent more patients testing positive for the flu than the past year, with tests showing that the 2009 H1N1 strain is most often identified among our patients. Flu patients have ranged in age from four months to 86 years old, with most less than 50 years of age.

But is it a cold or the flu? When you get the sniffles or a cough, it’s sometimes hard to tell the difference. Because there are literally thousands of viruses that cause the common cold, many strains of the flu, as well as variations in how people respond to them, there can be considerable overlap in the symptoms and severity of these two entities. It can be virtually impossible to tell the difference. It can be important, however, because unlike the common cold, the flu can result in pneumonia, hospitalization and death. There are, however, some guidelines that can help you determine when you should see a doctor.

Flu symptoms and treatment

Symptoms of the flu are typically sudden and severe and may include some or all of these symptoms: fever (frequently more than 103 degrees); uncontrollable dry cough; extreme fatigue or weakness; and headache and body aches. Mild runny nose and sore throat may also be present, and children may have an upset stomach, vomiting and diarrhea.

Sometimes I can tell immediately when a person has the flu. They feel so bad they just don’t care. They can tell me the exact date and time when they got sick, can’t stop coughing and it hurts to touch them almost anywhere. They prefer to lie down most of the time.

Support Local Journalism

If you have the flu, then you should be aware that it can be life-threatening. If you have any other underlying medical problems such as heart or lung disease, diabetes or if you are older than 65 years old, then you should get medical attention if symptoms are severe.

Once you have the flu, it can last anywhere from a few days up to two weeks. If you catch it within the first 48 hours of onset, you can go to the doctor and possibly get antiviral medication that can help reduce the severity and duration of symptoms. Doctors are encouraged to prescribe this medication only for people at high risk of complications, for whom it can be potentially life-saving. Antibiotics do not help the flu. Treatment is largely supportive and symptomatic. You should increase your intake of fluids to avoid dehydration, which would magnify the symptoms of weakness and fatigue. You should take a medication such as Tylenol, ibuprofen or naproxen as frequently as recommended on the package to help with body aches and headaches. (Note: You should not take medications containing aspirin.) You can try over-the-counter cough preparations, and most importantly, you should stay home and rest as much as possible to prevent you from infecting others.

Cold symptoms and Treatment

Typical cold symptoms are much milder and more gradual. They include stuffy or runny nose, sore throat, sneezing, cough, mild fatigue and mild fever (less than 100 degrees). Patients report that their symptoms may come and go. They probably have not missed work. If you suspect that you have a cold, treatment is symptomatic and can usually be accomplished with over-the-counter medications.

If your cold symptoms are still present and severe after 10-14 days or if you have developed localized sinus or ear pain, then you may want to see your doctor to see if you have another illness, such as a sinus or ear infection.


The best thing to do during cold and flu season is to take steps to avoid getting sick altogether. Here are a few things you can try:

1. Get the flu shot. The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention recommends everyone older than the age of six months get the vaccine, which is available throughout our community at pharmacies, Eagle County Public Health and medical offices. The most common strain of the flu seen in our area is the H1N1 strain, which is covered in the 2013-14 flu vaccine. All of the employees at Vail Valley Medical Center that are eligible for the vaccine have received it.

2. Get enough sleep. Studies have been done where they actually spray cold viruses up the nose of two groups of people. The first group gets an adequate amount of sleep, 8-9 hours per night. The second group is sleep deprived, getting only 5-6 hours per night. The ones who are sleep deprived get sick twice as often as the ones who have had adequate sleep.

3. Exercise (but not too much). Studies show that regular exercise, even just walking for 30 minutes a day, can reduce your chances of upper respiratory illness by 50-75 percent. Unfortunately, exercising vigorously for more than an hour per day is associated with an increased chance of illness.

4. Hand hygiene. Hand washing or use of hand sanitizer is associated with 20-50 percent decreased incidence of respiratory infection. This has been studied in school classrooms, college dorms and military barracks, but remember, it doesn’t take place of getting the flu shot.

5. Reduce stress. A high stress level is hard on your immune system and has been linked to increased incidence of upper respiratory illness.

6. Water gargling? Two studies out of Japan show that simple water gargling decreases incidences of colds by about a third. One of these studies included 20,000 preschoolers. Unlike many medical interventions, it’s cheap, free and harmless.

7. Probiotics. Since 70 percent of your immune system is concentrated around the GI tract, some early studies indicate that there may be some benefit to probiotics. However, more than 50 percent of probiotic supplements are shown to be inactive when examined by labs.

Other supplements? Unfortunately, no supplement has ever been proven effective to prevent the common cold in the general population, including vitamin A, C, D, E, echinacea, garlic, zinc or any combination of any supplement. That being said, there are studies that indicate supplementation with vitamin C and beta-glucan (found in mushrooms and brewers yeast/nutritional yeast) can reduce incidences of respiratory infections in people doing extreme endurance sports (i.e. marathon runners).

For more information on the flu, visit and search “flu” or

Dr. Dennis Lipton is an internal medicine physician at Vail Valley Medical Center, and physicians assistant S. Jason Moore, Ph.D., is an epidemiologist and trauma and critical care physician assistant at Vail Valley Medical Center.

Support Local Journalism