Eagle County Real Estate Market Report: Markets stabilize amidst continued buyer demand | VailDaily.com

Eagle County Real Estate Market Report: Markets stabilize amidst continued buyer demand

Michael Slevin
On Real Estate
Secluded at the Top of Singletree at 261 Mesquite Drive, this unique alpine getaway with 8,516 square feet, six bedrooms and seven bathrooms, plus separate caretaker house, sits on a one+ acre lot adjacent to National Forest lands and hiking trails. The main home features include a spacious great room with vaulted ceilings and towering windows that overlook a wrap-around deck with views to the New York Mountain and Arrowhead, along with a gourmet kitchen, see-through fireplace, breakfast nook, and two separate family rooms. Listed and sold by Alida Zwaan with Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Colorado Properties. The home sold for $4.995 million in August 2022.
Courtesy photo

Unlike the steady (frantic) pace of 2021, this year’s real estate market experienced some significant changes. While the first quarter was a follow-through of the hyper-activity our markets saw in 2020/2021, inflation and interest rate increases changed the pace of sales beginning in June. As a result, Eagle County’s residential real estate market declined by about 24% in dollar volume and 30% in units year-over-year. Much of the unit decline was in the local and bedroom communities that are historically more interest rate sensitive.  

The rapid changes are beginning to settle down. Interest rates have stabilized, and expectations are that they may trend down in 2023. Buyer activity remains elevated, yet buyers are increasingly more critical about pricing and the condition of properties and are either holding off until the right home comes along or adjusting offers to be more in line with market value. Pricing is a critical element for sellers in today’s market. Having the most up-to-date comparable sales and pricing homes for sale accordingly, in addition to having a home in the best condition, will yield the most successful result.

Luxury resort market

Offering views of Arrowhead and the New York Mountain Range, this custom-built home featuring 4,225 square feet,, four bedrooms and five bathroomsat 1420 Singletree Road in Edwards features an open-air, brightly lit great room and stone fireplace, hardwood floors, vaulted ceilings, open gourmet kitchen, three-car heated driveway, and walk-in wine cellar. Listed by Alida Zwaan with Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Colorado Properties. The home sold for $3.2 million in February 2022.
Courtesy photo

Alida Zwaan, an associate broker with Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Colorado Properties, notes that while the luxury market has flattened, it is still strong for right-priced homes at market value. “I have written two offers recently for full price that went up against multiple offers,” Zwaan said. “Some buyers are holding off, thinking the market will go down. But if they find the right home that fits their needs, they are willing to pay a fair price. The homes that aren’t selling are the ones that are priced too high, based on location and/or condition.”

Downvalley market

Located at 45 Eagle Ranch Road in Eagle, this five-bedroom, 3.5-bath home features an open-air floor plan seamlessly connecting the kitchen, dining, and living room areas, as well as a fenced-in back yard and two-car detached garage. Upgrades include newly refinished hardwood floors and interior paint. Listed by Chad Brasington with Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Colorado Properties for $899,000.
Courtesy photo

For both the luxury and downvalley markets, the biggest challenges are inventory and appropriate pricing. Chad Brasington, also an associate broker for Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Colorado Properties, notes that for the local market, a dramatic shift back to the norm is something every local buyer and seller truly wants and needs. “We can’t sustain artificially inflated home prices when it comes to the most important thing to every family that lives here…their home,” Brasington said.

Looking ahead, Brasington notes that for midvalley homes catering to locals, it’s important to remember there is a buying hiatus between Labor Day and Opening Day, in late November/early December.

Support Local Journalism

“If you are not under contract by the end of August, it is unlikely you will see anything until the second homeowners roll back into town in early December. When pricing a home, sellers need to flush out the memory of 2021 and early 2022 and shift their mindset to the more stable years of 2018 and 2019. It’s about market value not what you think your home is worth,” Brasington said.

Overall, there is a positive outlook for the new year. Today, as much as ever, the market is responding in line with macro factors that are influencing behavior. Neighborhoods throughout the county are adjusting differently based on buyer demand and circumstances (e.g., cash vs. financing), but with great snow, mountains fully operational, and elevated inventory, there is great excitement for a positive winter season and beyond.

Michael Slevin is the president and owner of Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Colorado Properties, started by his father, John, 52 years ago. The company has grown to 12 offices in 10 communities, spanning from Summit and Eagle Counties to the Western Slope.

Support Local Journalism