Time Machine: 120 years ago, Eagle attempts to wrest county seat away from Red Cliff

Eagle Valley Enterprise/Vail Daily archive
90 years ago
August 3, 1934
Seven miles of new highway between Eagle and Wolcott had been completed and was scheduled to open to traffic within a short time, the Eagle Valley Enterprise reported.
“This is a beautiful piece of highway engineering and construction,” the Enterprise reported. “The underpass and short bit of new highway at Gypsum is being rapidly completed this week, and it will be opened to traffic August 15.”
The highway department, however, had “forgotten the unfinished stretch of the highway across the county between Eagle and Gypsum, apparently,” according to the Enterprise. “This project, which includes the elimination of two of the most dangerous railroad crossings in this part of the state and some of the slickest dirt road in times of wet weather there is in this part of the county, has been surveyed and practically ready for contract for a year.”
100 years ago
August 1, 1924

Support Local Journalism
Emory Rose, an Eagle County man living on a homestead northwest of Wolcott, confessed to the sheriff that he had been manufacturing liquor after being taken into custody on a complaint of insanity.
“Rose was in Eagle last Saturday and showed signs of mental debility, his hallucination seeming to be that at some former period in his life he had participated in the hanging of a woman,” the Enterprise reported. “He was examined by Doctor Rucker Saturday; whose judgment was that Rose was losing his mind, but was not likely to become violent and might get over his fancy.”
The sheriff and county judge committed the demented man to the care of his brother.
“Before leaving town Saturday he confessed to the sheriff that he had been manufacturing liquor illicitly, and that he had a considerable stock on hand which he wanted to surrender, stating that this business was preying on his mind and he wanted to quit and start with a clean slate,” the Enterprise reported.
The sheriff accompanied Rose to his homestead, “where he was led to a most cunningly concealed still house, back in the hills on the north slope of Castle mountain — one which the federal officers had been trying to locate without success for some time,” the Enterprise reported. “Rose had found a spring in an apparently dry gulch, the water disappearing into the ground again a short distance from the spring, so that no one would suspect the presence of water for any purpose in the vicinity. Here he had a complete plant for the manufacture of liquor.”
Rose forfeited a 20-gallon keg and a 10-gallon keg filled with whiskey, along with a number of jugs of liquor and the still itself.
The sheriff “destroyed the plant and liquor and wiped the slate clean,” the Enterprise reported.
110 years ago
July 24, 1914
The region was reeling from what the Glenwood Post called the worst tragedy in the history of the city, as a local doctor in town murdered his two daughters, ages 12 and 10, before dying by suicide.
“From information received from parties who have been in Gleenwood, the man was crazy at the time he committed the horrible deed,” the Eagle Valley Enterprise reported.
120 years ago
July 29, 1904
Eagle was preparing to make another bid to take the county seat away from Red Cliff, the Eagle Valley Enterprise reported.
“After a lapse of nine years since the inauguration of the first contest for the removal of the county seat from Red Cliff, Eagle is making preparations to again place the matter before the people of the county,” the Eagle Valley Enterprise reported. “Our defeat in the former instance was based largely upon the assumption of the supreme court of the state, to which the people of Red Cliff had appealed the case after the fight had been won locally, that all legally constituted electors were privileged to vote upon the question of removal, whereas the contest had been made with taxpayers only permitted to vote.”
In the 9 years since Eagle last attempted to become the county seat, conditions had materially changed across Eagle County, the Enterprise reported.
What matters in your community, delivered daily.
Sign up for our morning newsletter at VailDaily.com/newsletter
“Then Red Cliff was the center of a lively mining and lumbering district, and Eagle represented a rather sparsely settled ranch community,” the Enterprise reported. “At the present time the mining and lumber values are insignificant as compared with the great agricultural interests, which have rapidly increased and will never reach their real value for many years to come. It is the farms which pay the greater proportion of our taxes, and the farmers feel that their interests should be considered.”
Eagle’s geographical location within Eagle County was another reason for the change, the Enterprise reported.
“The county seat remains perched away up in one corner of the county in a narrow canon, access to which is difficult by vehicle at all times of the year and practically impossible during the winter months,” the Enterprise reported. “Red Cliff is an inconvenient point at which to hold sessions of the district and county courts, mileage of witnesses and jurors counting heavily in the list of expenses.”


