Eagle County schools are betting on Ballot 5B as teachers get priced out of the valley 

Share this story
The Eagle County School District's is looking for a new source of funding for teacher salaries. On March 20, 2025, educators from all over the state, including the Eagle County School District, rallied outside the Colorado Capitol in Denver for better education funding.
Robert Tann/Vail Daily archive

After living in Eagle County as a first-year teacher at Avon Elementary School for over a year, Riley Hudnall ended up moving to the East Coast after struggling to afford living in the valley. She said the choice was a hard one to make, but in the end the expenses were just too much. 

“As much as I love it and I love showing up every day for my students, its really expensive to be here,” she said. “When I told everyone, I couldn’t even stand up there. I was sad I was moving and broke down in tears.”

Colorado is the fifth wealthiest state in the nation, and yet it is ranked 50th in teacher wage competitiveness. Educators are moving all around the state, just to find a role that could provide steady financial support. Eagle County School District is feeling the strain — and that’s why this November they are asking constituents to vote “yes” on their mill levy override ballot question. 



Ballot Issue 5B is a local property tax of an additional $10.1 million that would begin in 2027, with annual collections following. The estimated cost is about $11 per month for every $1 million of assessed value. The revenue generated would stay in the school district and could go towards retaining and attracting teachers and support staff, strengthening reading, writing and math instruction, restoring electives like art, music and physical education or ensuring student access to mental health professionals. 

In a recent interview with the Vail Daily, local school leaders said attracting and retaining teachers is their single biggest hurdle. According to the president of the Education Foundation of Eagle County, Wendy Rimel, when teachers leave, the district spends roughly $12,000 to replace each educator. The MLO would allow ECSD to offer salaries that can compete with neighboring districts.

Support Local Journalism




Eric Mandeville, principal of Eagle Valley Middle School, said they’ve had to make significant cuts in recent years as a consequence of staff numbers dropping. He said with fewer teachers, the schools have resorted to combining classes. This not only gives teachers more children to oversee and more workload to take on, but it also removes the opportunity to offer more classes and one-on-one time for teachers and their students. In part, the MLO wants to strengthen academic programs like math and writing, but they can only get so far if they don’t have the staff to do so. 

“The district needs to have a healthy, steady supply of high-quality teachers that are attracted to the area that want to live in Colorado, want to live in the mountains, and that’s hard to do when you can’t afford a house,” said David Russel, the principal of Gypsum Creek Middle School. 

Russell said they’ve had to make cuts in the number of programs they can offer. While GCMS has art and music classes, they’ve lost technology education. Interventionist opportunities and co-teaching for kids with disabilities have really taken a hit in recent years as well, he said. By having less staff, students’ academic growth falters. 

In the same conversation, Dana Harrison, principal of Avon Elementary, said her school is feeling the impact from all the staffing they’ve lost. “We are all doing so much more with less and have had to be creative to make things work,” she said.

All three leaders agreed that keeping teachers around gives the schools more opportunity to expand their professional development — progressing as a staff and building on the quality of pedagogy they can offer students. 

“Building more complex systems with people that have been here is much better for advancing what you want to do with growth and achievements for students,” said Russell. He said when they’re constantly replacing teachers, it feels like they’re starting over as a team every year. 

“The people that we do have, I think their ability to stay in this valley is extremely tenuous right now,” he added. 

That’s why they believe the MLO is essential to the school district’s growth. 

The Eagle County Democratic Party, in a recent statement, has announced its support for the MLO. The politcal party said without the funding, the school district, families, students and staff could face consequences. Meanwhile, the Eagle County Republican Party has recommended voting against the ballot issue. In part, local Republicans believe the measure is too broad, according to a statement from chairman Dan King. He shared that the party could possibly support an MLO that would fully go towards teachers’ salaries; however, King said that for the other items that the MLO could fund, they believe the school board should find other ways to pay for them. 

But for some programming, that may not be an option. According to Rimel, the school district offers in-school therapy programs that are entirely grant-funded by the district. However, she said that money is planned to run out in two years with no other funding sources in mind. What the MLO could do, she said, is provide financial support to the school district to keep these licensed therapists around. 

At Avon Elementary, Harrison has already seen their mental health options weaken as their full-time therapist reduced her work to part-time. Russell said he’s watched his feeder elementary schools struggle to keep people in those student-support positions. 

“Students aren’t prepared to learn until they are in a safe environment,” Harrison said. “We could not educate the students without that social-emotional support.” 

Everyone agreed that the hardest part of the battle is getting people without children to care. The principals all advocated that by generating more funding to support children, it will trickle into the community in the long run. 

“We provide the workforce with high-quality, critical thinkers, polite, former students, so whether you’re going to get your oil changed, whether you’re going to get onto a lift,” Mandeville said, “each time I travel or go anywhere, there are former students everywhere.” 

While the kids may add to the workforce, another topic that the local GOP brought to attention was whether a tax increase is the right move if affordability is such an issue. 

At GCMS, Russell said that the quality of the schools shapes the prices of homes. Good quality schools could bring value in property, he said, adding to market stability and overall financial fitness in the long run. 

“Anyone who owns property in any kind of location, one of the biggest factors for maintaining or improving the value of the property that you own here is the quality of the schools in the community,” he said. “When the quality of the schools of the community is not as high as it could be, you’re gonna have a harder time selling property or building value in your property, equity in your property, so that’s something people often lose sight of.”

In a later statement, Rimel added that Colorado has one of the lowest effective residential property tax rates in the country. “That doesn’t erase the affordability pressures families face here, but it matters as we weigh what we’re asking people to invest in our schools,” she said. 

“To hear over and over again that families want great schools, great jobs and safe neighborhoods … as a community we have to weigh the cost of this investment alongside the cost to our children, families and community of losing those opportunities,” she said. “An educated workforce and a thriving community begin with strong public schools.” 

Share this story

Support Local Journalism