Avon has a new procedure for Town Council members to remove one of their own

Multi-step process requires hearing, concurring vote of five council members

Share this story
Avon Town Council votes in new law creating procedure for council members to remove one of their own.
Zoe Goldstein/Vail Daily archive

For the first time, the Avon Town Council has a procedure to remove its members from office. 

During its regular meeting on Tuesday, July 23, the Town Council approved new rules for the removal of council members from serving on the council. The rules were drafted and presented by Nina Williams, the town’s attorney.

While Avon has had a process for removing members of the council via recall election, and council members could formerly be voted out via majority vote under Colorado Title 31, a process for the council to remove one of their own is new.



Although the removal of a council member from office is “unlikely,” according to Williams’ note in the Town Council meeting packet, having a legal mechanism for the removal allows all future Town Councils to be prepared in case of need.

Notably, the rules for removal allow for the removed member to run for and be voted onto council again in a future election at the will of the voters, rather than preventing the person from serving on council again.

Support Local Journalism




Causes for removal

The removal process involves several steps. 

First, a council member must commit one of the causes for removal listed under the new law. The causes for removal are varied, and all connect to a form of behavior unbecoming of a council member.

Causes that might lead to someone getting removed from the council include the following: Four consecutive or six total absences from council meetings or work sessions within a calendar year; deliberate or consistent neglect of or refusal to perform the duties of a council member; attending Town Council meetings while intoxicated; a conviction of a crime of moral turpitude; or violations of the Avon Town Council code of ethics, residency requirements, or employment relationships.

Crimes of moral turpitude include a wide range of crimes, including offenses against a person, like homicide; offenses against property, like arson; fraud-related charges, like money laundering; and offenses involving family relations, like domestic violence. The full list can be found in the council packet for the July 23 meeting.

Avon’s code of ethics for council members includes requiring that council members be “independent, impartial and responsible to the people.” Council members cannot use or manipulate information while on the council to aid their business proceedings and must disclose and potentially recuse themselves from decisions on conflicts of interest. Members of the council cannot have employment relationships with each other.

Next, a “charge for removal” of a council member can be enacted by four council members.

Due to Open Meetings Laws in Colorado, three or more council members cannot gather to discuss council or otherwise public business without noticing and holding the gathering as a public meeting. This also applies to emails, phone calls and other electronic forms of communication.

Starting the process

So how do council members communicate about the desire to remove one of their own?

For four or more members to advocate for removing one member of the council, a member would need to put the discussion on the agenda to take place at a regular or special council meeting. A charge for removal can be brought at a regular or special council meeting.

Following this, the council will hold a hearing for the charged council member. The charged council member will receive written notice of the charges and the date, time and place of the hearing at least 10 days before the hearing.

The hearing will be held publicly, and special counsel, rather than town staff, will be selected by the Town Council to conduct and present evidence in the hearing.

At the hearing, both parties will be able to have legal representation, present testimony and evidence, and cross-examine witnesses.


What matters in your community, delivered daily.

Sign up for our morning newsletter at VailDaily.com/newsletter


Following the end of the hearing, the council will vote on whether to remove the offending member. The council member who is the subject of the removal vote will not take part in the vote.

The council can then remove a member with a concurring vote of at least five members of the council.

“That’s a high number because you are all democratically elected,” Williams said at the council’s July 9 meeting.

If the charged member of the council is not removed by a vote of five (or more) members of council, they cannot be charged again for the same issue.

The seven members of the Avon Town Council unanimously approved the new law at the July 23 meeting. The rules will apply beginning 30 days after the vote.

Share this story

Support Local Journalism