Eagle County assessor’s race a choice between public-sector versus private-sector experience

Chris Dillmann/Vail Daily
The race for Eagle County assessor in the Nov. 3 election pits a professional with 2½ decades of experience in the office — Democrat Andie Noakes, the current chief deputy appraiser — against a political newcomer with an extensive background in private-sector finance and operations, Republican schoolteacher Christopher Buono.
Both candidates say partisan politics has no place in determining an assessor — an elected position responsible for evaluating and determining the market value of commercial and residential property for county tax purposes. In that sense, it may seem odd that it’s a partisan race.
“It does not make any difference whatsoever,” Noakes said of party affiliation in a recent phone interview. “There’s no rules for Democrats versus Republicans or any partisan part of this position. It’s the same rules. There’s very little discretion in how you follow the rules. So partisan politics does not play into this role at all.”
Asked if that’s because the state rules for assessment and property appraisal are so black and white, Noakes responded, “As much as appraisal can be, because appraisal is generally pretty gray. The rules are black and white. At the end of the day, it is still an opinion, but it’s an educated, informed opinion.”

Buono, a Battle Mountain High School social studies teacher who previously worked for IBM Global Services as a fractional CIO/COO and then launched, owned and operated Buon-Riche Foods out of Kansas City during the COVID-19 pandemic, agreed there is not much regulatory wiggle room in terms of determining property values.

Support Local Journalism
“Colorado law tightly regulates property valuation, including assessment methods and timelines,” Buono wrote in an email interview. “The assessor doesn’t control market prices, assessment rates, or mill levies. What we can control is the accuracy of property data, consistent application of valuation standards, quality assurance, transparency, community education and a fair, accessible appeals process.”
Buono agreed there’s no room for partisan politics in the Assessor’s Office, which is being vacated by the retirement of longtime Eagle County Assessor Mark Chapin, a Democrat.
“It’s unusual that largely administrative offices like assessor, treasurer and coroner are elected,” Buono wrote. “But appointment would likely place those decisions with county commissioners. Elections preserve independence, accountability and diversity of perspectives. Partisan politics shouldn’t influence property valuations; professional competence, fairness and public trust should guide the office.”
Noakes said electing those positions and maintaining independence is important.
“It is and actually kind of the same reason that (coroner’s candidate) Claire (Noble) said,” Noakes said, referring to another local contested partisan race. “The Assessor’s Office is responsible for determining value, and the commissioners and other parts of the county, they’re responsible for funding county projects and for spending the tax dollars. So, we’re one third of the pie. The taxing entities are a third, and then the assessment rates are another third.”
Buono said his private-sector experience, managing organizations and departments of up to 500 employees and $50 million in financial responsibility, compares favorably with Noakes’ extensive experience in the Assessor’s Office locally as a certified appraiser, statistician and manager.
“I’ve heard good things about Andie Noakes and respect her technical experience,” Buono wrote. “Running this office requires financial, systems and people management. I understand that she brings many years of assessment-system knowledge; I bring broader financial and organizational leadership experience. Technical assessment expertise can be developed, while effective leadership requires experience across multiple disciplines.”

Noakes said technical expertise counts for a lot, especially in a potentially volatile market.
“It’s a pretty technical position, and there’s lots of rules and regulations that define what we have to do, why, and when. So having that knowledge and understanding of the background is really important,” Noakes said, adding that assessments are always based on set timeframes for comparable sales prices.
“It’s challenging because we want to try and be as accurate as possible, and there are rules that we have to follow for time frames of sales data that we have to look at, and then we’re audited,” Noakes said. “So, we have to follow the rules and try and be accurate. But then when public perception hasn’t kept up with maybe the sales activity that’s happening, that can cause concern for some people.”
For instance, Eagle County’s market is currently undergoing some changes, with interest rates climbing and other external factors.
“Right now, the market is changing, and we are locked into the appraisal date of June 30 of 2026, so this past June,” Noakes said. “So, anything that happens from June to now, if the market keeps going down with interest rates or what have you, we’re still locked into June, and we can’t reflect what’s maybe happening right now.”
Buono agreed that the rules are the rules no matter the external forces impacting the market.
“The assessor cannot control economic conditions or housing markets,” Buono wrote. “We can ensure valuations accurately reflect market evidence within Colorado’s statutory framework, maintain reliable property records, monitor market trends, and apply consistent appraisal practices. Economic uncertainty makes accuracy, transparency, and a responsive appeals process especially important.”
Noakes said the rules do dictate the process, but fairness is the overriding concern.
“It’s mandated dates and information that we can rely on, and it has to be based on actual sales that have taken place and actual market data, and you can’t just rely on listing history or something that’s been on the market, listed and hasn’t sold,” Noakes said. “We want to try and be as accurate for everybody as possible. If we were just aiming for close enough, the guy that’s undervalued would be super happy. The guy that’s overvalued would be really unhappy with it. And we’d rather try and shoot for correct on everybody than close enough.”
Buono was asked why change is needed in the Assessor’s Office.
“Before deciding to run, I spoke with a few assessor’s office employees,” Buono wrote. “A recurring concern was that current leadership had become less focused and engaged. I respect the office’s professionals and their work. My goal isn’t to criticize anyone’s efforts but to reinvigorate the organization through attentive, proactive leadership.”
Finally, as a teacher, Buono was asked for his position on Eagle County School District Ballot Question 5B, a mill levy override to provide more money for local teachers struggling to make it in a resort community with extremely high housing prices and overall cost of living. Ballot Question 5B recently earned support from the county commissioners and most of the towns in Eagle County.
“Although I differ with some Republican colleagues and generally favor spending discipline over revenue increases, I support 5B,” Buono said. “As a teacher, former Exceptional Children’s Education Act officer, and former Eagle County School District Finance Committee member, I’ve seen our district’s lean operations firsthand. Without additional funding, teacher compensation will continue to lag behind neighboring districts.”










